Neuroscience Clerkship

 

 

DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF DEMENTIA

 

Alzheimer’s Disease

 (50-80%)

Lewy body dementia

(20%)

Mixed dementia (AD and vascular dementia)

(10%)

Depression

(5-10%)

Vascular dementia

(5%)

Metabolic disorders (B12 deficiency, hypothyroidism)

(<5%)

Infections (abscess, encephalitis)

(<5%)

Structural lesions (tumors)

(<5%)

Alcoholic dementia

(<5%)

Hydrocephalus (NPH)

 (<5%)

Pick’s disease and other degenerative disorders

(<1%)

Adopted from American Academy of Neurology: Continuum “Dementia” Feb 2004


Note that the most common cause of dementia by far is Alzheimer’s disease. This is followed by Lewy body dementia and mixed dementia. However, before categorizing a patient into one of these categories, it is essential to rule out any treatable or reversible causes of dementia as shown above in red.

Depression is very common in the elderly and may mimic dementia. This may be revealed by directly asking the patient or caregiver whether they notice any changes in mood, sleep patterns, appetite, inability to get pleasure from previously pleasurable activities. Clinical testing will reveal a poor concentration or frustration in answering the examiner’s questions. Often a neuropsychological testing will help uncover depression.

Metabolic disorders, may mimic dementia. The most common of these includes B12 deficiency and hypothyroidism. B12 deficiency may occur s/p gastric bypass surgery due to loss of intrinsic factor production. Pernicious anemia or malnutrition are other causes. In addition to dementia, the patient may also have subacute combined degeneration or peripheral neuropathy. Subacute combined degeneration is weakness and imbalance due to degeneration of corticospinal tracts and posterior columns respectively. The patient may have hyperreflexia on exam, weakness and loss of propioceptive and vibratory sense. The diagnosis of B12 deficiency is made by checking serum B12, homocysteine and methylmalonic acid (MMA) levels. Hypothyroidism may present as dementia. Patients may have other signs of hypothyroidism such as loss of energy, weight gain, hair loss, depression. Serum TSH is a good screen. Free T4 and T3 may be checked as well.

Infections should be suspected in the presence of fever, leukocytosis. The patient may have focal neurological findings with abscesses. Altered level of consciousness may raise suspicion as this is not found in dementia. Risk factors for HIV and syphilis should be sought. HIV and VDRL or RPR testing should be done in suspected patients. Neuroimaging may be useful in revealing abscess, meningeal enhancement, PML (in HIV). Lyme titers should be drawn in patients living in tick endemic areas. Lumbar puncture may be diagnostic, but should be done after neuroimaging to exclude a mass lesion. Although a transmittable disease and not an infection in the traditional sense, Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is a rapidly progressive and fatal dementia caused by abnormal prion proteins. In addition to cognitive changes, the patient usually has some combination of ataxia, myoclonus, visual impairments and severe sleep disturbances. Neuroimaging may show bright focal abnormalities in thalami and basal ganglia. EEG may show periodic sharp waves complexes. CSF may show elevated 14-3-3 protein. There is no treatment for CJD.

Structural lesions as a cause of dementia are uncommon, however should be suspected if any focal neurologic signs are discovered. Meningioma is a slow growing benign tumor that may produce gradual changes in cognitive function mimicking a dementia. Other tumors may also produce dementia. MRI with gadolinium will reveal the mass lesion. Other structural lesions include chronic subdural hematoma. Risk factors include anticoagulation with warfarin, falls, and elderly patients. CT head or MRI usually detect this.

Alcoholic dementia should be suspected in patients with a history of alcohol abuse. Any patient presenting with change in mental status should receive IV thiamine to avoid precipitating Wernicke’s encephalopathy. The etiology of alcoholic dementia is probably multifactorial, but probably involves nutritional deficiency and/or direct toxic effect of alcohol. On exam, patients may have ataxia due to vermal degeneration. A peripheral neuropathy is also commonly present.

Hydrocephalus may mimic dementia. Normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH) is a triad of: dementia, urinary incontinence and gait ataxia. Neuroimaging using CT scan or MRI shows large ventricles out of proportion to cortical atrophy. LP usually shows normal pressure, however continuous lumbar pressure monitoring usually shows periodic rises in CSF pressure. Treatment of NPH involves CSF shunting.

Alzheimer’s disease, the most common form of dementia is an insidious, slowly progressive dementia. The hallmark is memory loss, usually starting with short-term loss, then progressing to long-term. Multiple cognitive areas may be affected including memory, naming, spatial abilities, language, praxis, executive function. Personality is usually preserved until late in the disease. Diagnosis is based on diagnostic criteria with exclusion of reversible causes. Treatment is with acetylcholinesterase inhibitors such as donepezil, rivastigmine or galantamine, however these do not stop the overall progression of the disease. Vitamin E may have a marginal benefit, but newer studies indicate a possible increase in cardiovascular risk. Memantine is a newly FDA approved treatment that involves the blockade of glutamate that is thought to be neurotoxic.

Lewy Body dementia is an underrecognized cause of dementia. The Lewy body is a neuropathological entity that is associated with Parkinson’s disease. Clinical features of Lewy body dementia include cognitive impairment, sleep disturbance, fluctuating course, visual hallucinations, executive dysfunction. There may be signs of Parkinson’s disease such as bradykinesia, tremor and rigidity. Autonomic dysfunction is common (orthostatic hypotension, urinary incontinence, constipation) Treatment with acetylcholesterase inhibitors and memantine may be helpful. Symptomatic treatment of hallucinations, sleep disturbances, parkinson’s features and dysautonomia are helpful.

Vascular dementia may be difficult to distinguish from Alzheimer’s disease. A step-wise course related to repeated strokes may suggest vascular dementia. A history of diabetes or HTN may raise suspicion for this form of dementia. MRI may show multiple cerebral infarcts. The Hachinski scale may help differentiate vascular dementia from Alzheimer’s, although these two entities may coexist. A score>7 indicates vascular dementia, whereas < 4 indicates Alzheimer’s disease. Treatment of vascular dementia is symptomatic with acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and modification of vascular risk factors.

Frontotemporal dementia is a rare dementia that preferentially involves frontal and temporal lobes. Onset may be < 65 years. Personality change and emotional changes occur early in the disease. Executive dysfunction occurs early. Altered speech production occurs early. Memory dysfunction does not occur early on. Spatial orientation is usually preserved initially. Imaging shows frontal lobe and temporal lobe atrophy out of proportion to parietal lobe and other cortical areas.


Other Neurodegenerative Disorders Associated with Dementia


The disorders above are considered in the differential diagnosis of dementia. However, there are other neurodegenerative disorders that may be associated with an associated dementia late in their course. Among these disorders include:

•  Huntington's Disease

•  Parkinson's Disease

•  Progressive Supranuclear Palsy

•  Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)

•  Spinocerebellar Degeneration


Diagnostic Tests for Dementia


In the evaluation of dementia, the 2004 AAN practice guidelines recommend:

•  Routine neuroimaging (MRI)

•  B12

•  Thyroid testing

•  Screening for depression

Routine screening for syphilis, HIV and other etiologies of dementia are not recommended in the absence of risk factors.